31 Flavors of Inclusionary Zoning: Comparing Policies from San Francisco, Washington, DC, and Suburban Boston
- Schuetz, Jenny
- Meltzer, Rachel
- Been, Vicki
Over the past several decades, inclusionary zoning (IZ) has become an increasingly popular, but sometimes controversial local means of producing affordable housing without direct public subsidy. The conversation about IZ has thus far largely ignored variations in the structure of IZ policies, although these variations can impact the amount of affordable housing produced and the effects of IZ on production and prices of market rate housing. This paper provides a detailed comparison of the ways in which IZ programs have been structured in the San Francisco and Washington metropolitan areas and in suburban Boston. The authors created a unique dataset on IZ in these three regions by combining original data collected from several previous surveys. They used these data to compare the prevalence, structure, and affordable housing output of local IZ programs. In the San Francisco Bay Area, IZ programs tend to be mandatory and apply broadly across locations and structure types, while including cost offsets and alternatives to onsite construction. In the Washington, DC, area, most IZ programs are also mandatory, but have broader exemptions for small developments and low-density housing. IZ programs in the Boston suburbs exhibit the most heterogeneity. They are more likely to be voluntary and to apply only to a narrow range of developments, such as multifamily housing, or within certain zoning districts. The amount of affordable housing produced under IZ varies considerably, both within and across the regions. There is some evidence that IZ programs that grant density bonuses and exempt smaller projects produce more affordable housing.
Access full text at
Our database on land use research is reserved for members of the Partnership for Sustainable Communities. Join our growing list of members!
Membership is very inexpensive click here to view your options. In addition to unlimited access to our database of abstracts, members of the Partnership for Sustainable Communities receive many other benefits.
Join today and get the tools you need to make good land use decisions. You'll also be supporting our advocacy and research efforts.